The Aristocrats

[tommytimp]

I didn't think Drew's version was all that funny. I don't think he's all that funny to begin with. He's like Jeffrey Ross-not as funny as he thinks, but good at getting funny people to be funny.

[memememe76]

Pretty good movie, if tiring after awhile.

My favourite versions: the card guy (the best), South Park, the mime (although I suspect it's only funny if you know the joke already), and the guy with the dummy. Hmmm, I only like the ones with something "extra." Guess that means I don't like the joke in of itself. I still don't really get why I should laugh at the punchline.

Phyllis Diller is OLD.

[cleangenie]

Was Jon Stewart funny?

[memememe76]

Not really. He was just commenting on the joke without telling his own version.

[marywebgirl]

But Jon did look scorching hot IMO.

[Deleted]

Watched it a couple days ago. Liked it but I think it went on too long. They wasn't quite enough to make a movie out of it. But some great ideas and insights.

The Eric Cartman version was the funniest.

[Deleted]

I am watching this right now via Netflix and the whole thing is just really self-congratulatory. Like "My aren't we all such fantastic comedians who are so skilled and unique in our own brands of humor. Don't you wish you were in our club?" and then they all tell this joke which isn't funny and stops being shockingly interesting almost immediately.

[Deleted]

Yeah, Jensational, my interest waned fairly quickly. I did like the one guy - I forget his name - with the gorilla named Daisy, though.

But dude, Bob Saget -- eye sockets? AIIIE.