Survivor

[LurkerNan]

James has both the hidden immunity idols, so does that mean there will be a fourth immunity idol? And is there some rule that says no one can steal the idols from James' backpack? Because I'd've pinched that thing a long time ago if I was the skinny Mormon dude.

[forever1267]

that was my only guess with the extra tribal council, but I don't know what the rules are either. Since, um, Gay Mormom Flight Attendent Guy basically gave one away to James, it should go to him, but who knows?

I don't like the fact that, in the previews, Amanda might go against her comrades. She's my Office Pool choice! I want to win this game!!

[tabby]

forever, I think Amanda may have a fighting chance at this point. She convinced Todd to blindside James (and that was classic). She seems to be pretty well-liked. She could be a contender here, and I never would have thought that back at the beginning.

The "we have unfinished business" drama followed by a reward challenge was kind of lame, but it did seem to make the players crap themselves, so ok. Excellent reward, though.

[prydainprincess]

Aw, James! Why didn't you use it? I was rooting for you.

Still, I think he has the best attitude of any player I've ever seen. During his closing statements he realized what he did was stupid, but he wasn't beating himself up over it because it is a game and he recognizes it. He also seemed to know that the other people did what made sense for them, didn't hear any neg comments about him.

[Deleted]

Yes, I noticed his attitude too, which makes me wish he won even more. He should have used ONE of the idols to insure his position.
I'm also wondering how they will eat? Seems he was up and making fire, getting water and catching breakfast while they still slept.

[indygirl]

I'm just happy that my early favorite didn't reveal himself to be some tremendous jackass as so many of my early picks do. Bye James! I probably won't watch anymore without ya!

[Mugsy]

I really don't understand why he didn't use one of his idols. He had two, and agreed with the others that none of them felt safe at this point. If only he had used it, then that annoyingly arrogant Todd would be gone.

I like PG, even if the other Survivors don't.

[soul]

Uh... PG bugs. Earlier in the game, she was very much wanted to be the tribal leader. Now, that she's an underdog, she doesn't know where to strike. First, she throws a competition, and then she barks at James for not perfoming well for another competition.

[Mugsy]

According to TWOP (where I was digging around on the weekend for "fun"), there is going to be an All-Star 2. Names being tossed around (and frankly, I don't remember who most of these people are, now that there's been 15 (!) rounds) are Cirie, crazy cigarette-quitting Shane, and Julie, who is Jeff Probst's girlfriend.

Now Julie bothers me, not because she actually bothers me, but because I don't think they can have her as a contestant if Peachy is the host. Not only is it unethical, aren't there game show rules about relatives or something? Even your little small town grocery store prize draws are off limits to employees' relatives. Surely with all the quiz show scandals of the 50s, Mark Burnett would not be stupid enough to let the host's girlfriend be a contestant. Waaay too much room for accusations of favourtism, fixed challenges, leading tribal council questions, etc.

[canuckcutie]

Ugh another all-star. The 1st few seasons the contestants were pretty memorable but since then they've all kinda blurred together for me. Unless Colby & Rupert are coming back again I'm not interested.

I think you are right mugsy it would be totally unethical to have Jeff's gf on the show esp as he does have a habit of asking pointed tribal questions just to shake things up. Saying that she'd probably have a great big target on her back because of her association with Jeff,